

crystlshake wrote:I think there was some archery in the Swan Princess story. I think it has a Russian origin. Im at a loss for assasins short of historical ones. The only part of your cross over im at all familiar with is Ranma so im not really sure of the type of leniancey or target your looking for.





DCG wrote:How the heck is ranma a rider?


Knight of L-sama wrote:DCG wrote:How the heck is ranma a rider?
Wild Horse. It's pushing a bit I know but unarmed fighters don't fit all that well. I could have snuck him in as Assasin via the Umi-sen-ken or Lancer via the final fight with Saffron but neither of them seemed to fit right.
And pspinler, I'm trying to avoid the western European legends since between the ones I've got and those from the game I feel that they've been raided enough already.

GenocideHeart wrote:Knight of L-sama wrote:DCG wrote:How the heck is ranma a rider?
Wild Horse. It's pushing a bit I know but unarmed fighters don't fit all that well. I could have snuck him in as Assasin via the Umi-sen-ken or Lancer via the final fight with Saffron but neither of them seemed to fit right.
It's pushing it A LOT. Wld Horse is simply his name's translation. It's not something he's KNOWN for.
He's much more known for flipping out when near cats - he'd fit much better as a Berserker. Setting him up as a Rider is just plain weird, especially since his name is in Japanese, and last I checked, the TYPE MOON Universe has its own language - how else can heroes of different countries and times understand each other?
So just a name that can, or can not, be translated as something is going to have little to no effect on Ranma's Heroic Spirit form, especially since it was used as his given name and nothing more. Would you expect Herb's name to affect him? It's the legend surrounding a Heroic Spirit that shapes what he or she is.
Hell, since he's known to have a magical curse, you could even make a better case for him being a Caster than a Rider. Rider is about the least appropriate class for him.
Just my $0.02.

Nested quotes are not allowed. This is when you are quoting the quotes of someone else's quotes. It is lazy and clutters.

Knight of L-sama wrote:Well Caster is probably the silliest class for Ranma becuase it's one of the things he's most definitively not. That class is reserved for those who were magicians/spell casters in life.
And the TYPE-MOON Universe doesn't have it's own language. The characters speak Japanese becuase most of them are Japanese. (Though Rin also speaks German) When it comes to the Servants it's no great leap of logic to assume that the Holy Grail or the Throne of Heroes includes some sort of translation ability, especially since otherwise only Archer and Assasin would have been able to make themselves understood. Giglamesh would have spoken only a dead language, while Saber, Lancer and the three Greeks would have spoken only such archaic versions of their languages that modern day speakers wouldn't be able to understand them.
Anyway I've also refined exactly why Ranma is Rider in the story as well. Since so many of his attack names have animal names making up part of them as and since Rider classification seems to involve controlling animals as a servants the attacks like the Mokou Takabisha and Hiryu Shoten Ha are actually going to manifest as animal shaped auras (which the Hiryu Shoten Ha sometimes does in anime canon already).
lwf58 wrote:I didn't write 'em; I just gotta enforce 'em. Since this is the first warning, no penalties. Just don't repeat it.

Knight of L-Sama wrote:I am currently writing a Fate/Stay Night/Ranma crossover with Saotome Ranma having been summoned as Rider for the 6th Grail War.
However I'm lacking ideas for Archer and Assasin. I'd personally prefer to avoid East Asian or Western European myths/legend since I've already raided them for my existing heroes
Frog wrote:Assassins are, from what I've been able to glean from game fansites, supposed to only be Hassan Sabbah's.
The one of the 5th war is an exception as he was the summon of a summon. If you do not want to use a Hassan Sabbah, might I suggest Miyamoto Musashi? As his mythological rival was summoned an Assassin it makes sense to me that he would too.
Knight of L-Sama wrote:Wild Horse. It's pushing a bit I know but unarmed fighters don't fit all that well. I could have snuck him in as Assasin via the Umi-sen-ken or Lancer via the final fight with Saffron but neither of them seemed to fit right.
Daniel Jess Gibson wrote:the Thuggee (sp?) the followers of Kali.

Users browsing this forum: No registered users