by FOG3 » Fri Dec 19, 2008 11:03 am
Ranma's less meaningfully quantifiable then Looney Tunes.
How can use assume identical properties to RL rock when they have none of the characteristics of RL rock? RL rock is a ceramic or if you prefer is dominated by ionic bonding, which makes the material hard but also insures plastic deformation is impossible on the molecular level. Hence real rock will shatter along grain boundaries or powder when pushed past its elastic deformation limits. This is made worse by the fact Ranmaverse rock has been shown to cave, which is not possible unless you're going to argue the insane, as a solid like solid rock already has its atoms arranged in a tight pack configuration meaning there is no empty space to collapse without collapsing the atoms themselves. The work around is you have interstitual pockets of gas which is highly compressible.
To get the kind of deformation we see is pretty much covalent exlusive territory. The strongest form of that with interstitual gas pockets is Styrofoam which has radically different properties then rock because of the different molecular bonding and the interstitial gas pockets. Material properties are indivisible from the molecular bonding type and otherwise so basically that renders every last number derived from stuff related to "rock" or building materials questionable at the least, as valid as a random number picked out of the air in fact.
And that's just some of the more blatantly obvious problems.
Everything in Ranma is simply designed to operate its over the top humor style while alluding to the antics of martial arts films. Even Genma and Soun are almost a straight rip off of a near identical pair of characters right down to character design in a farcical Bruce Lee rip off film from the 70s called the Blind Fist of Bruce Li. I should probably mention these guys arranged fights for the prodigee, where the guys were *cough*cough* paid to lose.
A quantified style doesn't suit it for writing purposes at all, Ranma 1/2 falls apart well before you get that serious just due to character wackiness. Slapstick taken seriously is pretty much a flat out no-no. So what's the point? Why not just use Yu Ominae of Spriggan, whose from a series designed from the base up for serious combat and to be taken seriously?