Page 1 of 1

Fate/stay night crossovers were Shirou is a girl?

PostPosted: Sat Feb 07, 2015 12:11 pm
by Blackcat101
Be it a wish go wrong, being reborn in another universe, or getting a second chance, I have yet to find any crossover were Shirou Emiya from Fate/ Stay Night is or becomes a girl. So if anyone finds one of these, could they please link them here? Thank you.

Re: Fate/stay night crossovers were Shirou is a girl?

PostPosted: Sun Feb 22, 2015 10:03 pm
by LunaInverse
https://www.fanfiction.net/s/10570593/1 ... with-Sword
its a cross over with Toaru Majutsu no Index

Re: Fate/stay night crossovers were Shirou is a girl?

PostPosted: Sat Mar 07, 2015 6:15 pm
by Blackcat101
I found a few more, but is not what I was looking for as Shirou being born female does not count for what I am looking for -_-

Re: Fate/stay night crossovers were Shirou is a girl?

PostPosted: Sat Mar 07, 2015 7:38 pm
by PCHeintz72
Blackcat101 wrote:I found a few more, but is not what I was looking for as Shirou being born female does not count for what I am looking for -_-

Then what you want likely would not be all that common... Fate/Stay night really had nothing in it, at least the anime, that would allow for spontaneous gender changes.

Re: Fate/stay night crossovers were Shirou is a girl?

PostPosted: Sun Mar 08, 2015 12:40 am
by Blackcat101
PCHeintz72 wrote:Then what you want likely would not be all that common... Fate/Stay night really had nothing in it, at least the anime, that would allow for spontaneous gender changes.


Let's see...

Powerful magical vampires (Death Apostles)

Reality Marbles...

Wish granting evil device...

Alternate realities...

Plus is part of a larger universe were shape-changing magic is slightly more common.

And is heavily hinted any magic considered dangerous is heavily suppressed unless is in control of the Clock Tower.

Anyway, I found another one:

https://www.fanfiction.net/s/6895017/1/ ... atic-Chaos

Re: Fate/stay night crossovers were Shirou is a girl?

PostPosted: Sun Mar 08, 2015 1:11 am
by PCHeintz72
Blackcat101 wrote:Let's see...

Powerful magical vampires (Death Apostles)

Reality Marbles...

Wish granting evil device...

Alternate realities...

Plus is part of a larger universe were shape-changing magic is slightly more common.

And is heavily hinted any magic considered dangerous is heavily suppressed unless is in control of the Clock Tower.

You misunderstood my point... it is not that you cannot have gender changing magic in Fate/Stay Night (or Type Moon in general for that matter)... It is actually far, far more likely and even easier to accept to have it in that than say, 'You're Under Arrest', which does not really lend itself well to magic in it of any kind...

Nor is it that such cannot exist, as we have a couple now in this thread to prove me wrong were that the point.

No...

It is that while we actually have the summoning of heroes of gender that are opposite of public belief (aka Saber), that issue can be explained away in any number of methods, (including history simply being wrong and she having been successful in hiding her identity). We do not actually see any evidence in mainline canon of any such thing being possible.

So... while it is not that you cannot find such stories, it is that they would be far rarer than in a series that *does* specifically have transformational means, be it magical or otherwise.

Shrugs, I am not really against it or for it in a story (I actually have read that one with Shirou that had one chapter of him in ZNT as female), though I fail to see it as a plot point in and of itself being strong enough for me to want to read something on that alone.

Re: Fate/stay night crossovers were Shirou is a girl?

PostPosted: Sat Dec 19, 2015 12:33 am
by UnlimitedBladeShirou
I am the bone of my Fandom.

Its implied that Mordred is the result of such magic being cast on Arturia/Saber.
That or she was turned into a hermaphrodite for the time needed to conceive Mordred.

So as I pray, Unlimited Fanfic Works

Re: Fate/stay night crossovers were Shirou is a girl?

PostPosted: Sat Dec 19, 2015 4:45 am
by PCHeintz72
There is one that just updated... To Ignite a Flame by hubbabubbagump. it is a High School DxD and a Fate Stay Night Cross....

Re: Fate/stay night crossovers were Shirou is a girl?

PostPosted: Sun Dec 20, 2015 10:48 am
by LunaInverse
Yay, thanks for finding another fanfic with fem!shirou.

Re: Fate/stay night crossovers were Shirou is a girl?

PostPosted: Sun Dec 20, 2015 8:32 pm
by kaorou
PCHeintz72 wrote:It is that while we actually have the summoning of heroes of gender that are opposite of public belief (aka Saber), that issue can be explained away in any number of methods, (including history simply being wrong and she having been successful in hiding her identity). We do not actually see any evidence in mainline canon of any such thing being possible.

So... while it is not that you cannot find such stories, it is that they would be far rarer than in a series that *does* specifically have transformational means, be it magical or otherwise.

Shrugs, I am not really against it or for it in a story (I actually have read that one with Shirou that had one chapter of him in ZNT as female), though I fail to see it as a plot point in and of itself being strong enough for me to want to read something on that alone.


Saber being female has an rather easy reason. for quite a while the writer had an female main with arthur as her summon in mind but midway they got concern due the marketing and changed shirous gender. And since the main pairing wouldnt work anymore with two males arthut had to become a female. but that has nothing do do with the story ^^

For more infos look here http://typemoon.wikia.com/wiki/Ayaka_Sajyou:
She is the main character of the original Fate/stay night novel. It was felt that she would not appeal to the target audience of the visual novel, so she was dumped in favor of Shirou to be more appealing. In Prototype it is revealed that her older sister Manaka Sajyou along with her father Hiroki Sajyou died eight years ago in the previous Holy Grail War.



Thats assuming you didnt know, which i somewhat doubt through xD

Re: Fate/stay night crossovers were Shirou is a girl?

PostPosted: Tue Dec 22, 2015 7:22 pm
by LunaInverse
Type moon is one of my favorite fandoms (not sure of a better term) I will frequently read large parts of the wiki to gain more understanding of it, like search shirou then click the link to saber and from thete click another link to avalon, then another until I've been on the wiki for a few hours.

Re: Fate/stay night crossovers were Shirou is a girl?

PostPosted: Tue Dec 22, 2015 8:52 pm
by UnlimitedBladeShirou
One thing is for sure... when in doubt, blame Zelretch!