by Wyrd » Sun Oct 24, 2010 11:54 am
My vote is skewed a bit by which ones I've seen best done. I would love to see a 'someone else from NWC as Senshi' fic that didn't have Ranma as a senshi, but I haven't seen any that did that, much less did them well. I've seen several that had someone related to an SM member, but in pretty much every case it was either too small a part of the story to really qualify as a crossover or was badly written. I've seen one that I can think of that Ranma was related to Usagi as a major plot element, with Ranma not being a Senshi, that I thought was well written. Tuxedo Kamen gets almost no love from fanfic writers, so I'm not surprised that someone else being him got no votes, though I think it could make a good story. I can enjoy a good relationship story, but the vast majority of the ones I've seen either have Ranma as a Senshi, are less than two chapters long, or are harem fics, with almost no focus on the SM character. As a result of all of this, 'Ranma as a Senshi' had to get my vote, despite the fact that I think there is serious potential in some of the other possibilities that just isn't being explored.