The quarterly reign thing sounds good. Id say use the moon queen and cat advisor titles for those leaving the recipient with no option to change it(with or without a custom image like a medal for the skirt counter ). Since this is a unique acknowledgement and you want others to recognize what they recieved the title for (encourage good behavior as it were). It would also be a lot more organized than having 3 random custom titles pop up every 3 months.
As far as rewarding titles for other achievements, Id leave it up to person sponsoring the contest as to whether they want to provide a unique title/counter badge that they already have ready that relates to the contest (thus making recognition for the achievment easy), or giving them the honor of creating their own custom title and or counter badge(a posibly more attractive option for spamville regulars to add character flavor text) which must pass aproaval.
Really between the two locations it gives the option for two titles by including text in the image field. Depending on where you want to encourage more activity you can make the awards available in different threads.
Flavor wise the image would probably be better associated with the heavy contributions like fan art or fic submission (optional for good color comentary or other regions) as it has the most visability for attracting the eye and shouting 'Hey! I contribute meaningful and/or substantial stuff to the site.' The text is less visable but more easily customized (requiring less work than image creation when starting from scratch) and could be available for any contribution/effort that the admins or provider deems worthy.
Some nominees who havent been mentioned yet would be:
lwf58- hes good at the rules thing and helping people with problems, prompt to respond and provides useful links in his signiature (He was patient with helping me get my avatar image up and working properly and responded quickly and thouroughly to my questions)
Cyber Skaarj- Im not sure how active he's been lately as ive spent more time in spamville, but im pretty sure he contributed to some of the discussions that were raging in the sailor moon or ranma threads, hes also made several animated avatars for various memebers of the site, for the Junsenkyo cursed spamvillians thats pretty considerable. And not only is he good at making them but he's fast too! (Thanks again!)
Sunshine Temple- Short and to the point like a sawed off shot gun, if the thread gets off topic it better shape up or BLAM! The Return and normal admin duties speak for themselves as far as contributions go (and thats without getting under the hood). Somehow either thrue a combination of preciese posting and avatar image puts the fear of god into forum anarchists everywere. If keeping the forums from degenerating into a mess of disorganized garbage that people wouldnt want to sift thrue for the good stuff doesnt deserve a nomination I dont know what does.
All of the nominees on lwf58's list contributed on some level of drawing me to these boards thrue meaningful discussion, wonderful prose, or playfull banter. A special thanks to all of them for making me feel welcome and keeping me coming back daily (or as close as I can manage) for more!










