by SpaceKnight of Chaos » Fri Sep 17, 2010 9:35 am
For a while now, I've been of the opinion that the reason Ranma, Genma and the Guide ended up at Nyuchiezu, with the Saotomes still in cursed forms, is because they fled Ryoga's quite justifiable rage at Genma and the Guide for trying to boil him. We don't see him attack them in his canonical flashback, but given the situation and who we're talking about, it makes sense that Genma and the Guide would run off, snatch up the unaware Ranma in the process, and then lose Ryoga before heading to the close-by village of the Joketsuzoku, given what's happened to Ryoga and who he is at this early stage in the saga.
Anyway, my question/idea is: what if Ryoga actually learned that Ranma was the one who cursed him before any of them left Jusenkyo? How would things change as a result of that?
The basic scenario in my head is that, when Genma brings Ryoga to the Guide for cooking, Ranma shows up before Ryoga gets dunked into the hot water. Perhaps making some idle comments about how boiling the pig is cruel, and/or wasting hot water, Ranma steals a small amount of it, after Ryoga's had a good chance to see "her" and realise that this is the girl who knocked him into the Spring of Drowned Pig, and then reverts to his human self, who Ryoga recognizes. Ryoga then changes back himself, whether by the Guide dunking him in or by attacking the Guide so he can leap into the boiling water. Scalded and absolutely furious, Ryoga attacks all three of them indiscriminately, causing them to run off and escape him, ending up going to Joketsuzoku and more or less acting as in canon. So, given that Ranma will be going into Joketsuzoku and end up eating the banquet as a male, and Ryoga is now perfectly aware that Ranma is not only in the area but cursed him "on purpose", what's likely to develop? How would this affect the Nerima scenario?
To share my own thoughts on the matter...
Because Ranma is still Ranma, he's just in his proper gender this time, I see him eating the prize as in canon and challenging Shampoo, but this time she ends things by giving Ranma the fan-dubbed 'Kiss of Marriage'. Now, the Guide may or may not be able to "translate" what this means to Genma, but Ranma's going to be fairly spellstruck (he is shown in both canons as being stunned and pleased at getting the Kiss of Death -- until he finds out what it means), and if Genma isn't immediately alerted to the fact that Shampoo's basically just declared herself Ranma's wife, he may be willing to stay here awhile: not only is it a form of civilisation, it's got lots of martial arts training to do/techniques to learn, it's close to Jusenkyo so he and Ranma can look in to their cures, and it's (hopefully) shelter from Ryoga (they don't know he's gotten lost).
Of course, nothing lasts forever; Mousse's rage over how Ranma is "stealing" his Shampoo, whether or not Ranma is at all thinking of him and Shampoo as more than friends (depending on minutia, Ranma may think of them as friends while wishing to be more, or may actually be aware she's attracted to him and responding - keep in mind, unlike canon, she hasn't dashed her initial attractiveness by trying to kill him, even if he's not aware that she thinks of him as her husband-to-be) isn't any obstacle... but, either Genma's going to do something stupid, he's going to find out at last that Shampoo and Ranma have been betrothed by the backwards laws of this place (or, alternatively, he may think that Ranma is getting too "attached" to Shampoo for the Tendo pledge's own good), or Ryoga's going to make an attack on the village severe enough that the Saotomes run off to save themselves.
The end result is that Ranma and Genma are going to head back to Japan while still being cursed (the possibility does strongly exist that they may have cures coming to them in the future), and, once there, Genma is naturally going to declare it time that Ranma head to the Tendo Dojo and wed one of Soun's daughters. This time, however, Ranma's hesitance towards the engagement is going to be stronger than canon because there's already a girl he likes and may have spent time bonding with.
Water, water, everywhere, and all was cursed and black!
Drowned ones cast bad spell and out come pig, girl, duck, panda!
Swirl, swirl, slithery pond, and join with magic spring!
Swirl, swirl, dirty pond, and rid the cursed sting!
Here my prayer, I beg you please!
Now turn these curses BACK!
http://www.issendai.com/rpgs/japanese-boys-names.shtml
http://www.issendai.com/rpgs/japanese-girls-names.shtml