Anime-Akane's Good, Bad & Ugly list

[SpaceKnight of Chaos]

So, how exactly does the Net Good stat work bissek?

Okay, now that Anime-Akane is done (bar the adjustments for corrected ? marks), how do the anime versions of the girls stack up against A: each other, B: their manga counterparts, and C: the manga counterparts of the other girls?

So, will you be wanting me to do tallies for the anime versions of Ranma's rivals? If yes, who exactly will I need to cover? And are there any special "circumstances in general" I need to take into account (for example, giving Happosai a G for offering Ranma a bra, because in his warped world view that's an extremely generous act, even if Ranma despises it)?

[bissek]

Now for comparisons of all the girls.

The transition from manga to anime has done the following to Shampoo:

% Good: Improved
% Bad: Improved
% Ugly: Improved

Magnitude of best moment: Improved
Magnitude of worst moment: Improved

% Ugliness: Improved
Ave Ugliness: Improved

Ave Net Good: Improved

To Ukyo:

% Good: Improved
% Bad: Improved
% Ugly: Worsened

Magnitude of best moment: Improved
Magnitude of worst moment: Worsened

% Ugliness: Improved
Ave Ugliness: Worsened

Ave Net Good: Improved

To Kodachi:

% Good: Improved
% Bad: Improved
% Ugly: Improved

Magnitude of best moment: Improved
Magnitude of worst moment: Worsened

% Ugliness: Improved
Ave Ugliness: Worsened

Ave Net Good: Improved

To Akane:

% Good: Improved
% Bad: Improved
% Ugly: Worsened

Magnitude of best moment: Improved
Magnitude of worst moment: Worsened

% Ugliness: Worsened
Ave Ugliness: Improved

Ave Net Good: Improved

Now, to rank characters in order so far.

In manga:

From best to worst, in

% Good:
1. Ukyo 2. Ryoga. 3. Akane 4. Shampoo 5. Happosai 6. Kodachi

% Bad:
1. Ukyo 2. Ryoga 3. Akane. 4. Shampoo 5. Kodachi 6. Happosai

% Ugly:
1. Ukyo 2. Akane 3. Ryoga 4. Happosai 5. Shampoo 6. Kodachi

Best moment:
1. Ryoga 2. Akane. 3. Shampoo 4. Ukyo 5. Happosai 6. Kodachi

Worst moment:
1. Ukyo 2. Kodachi 3. Happosai 4. Ryoga 5. Akane 6. Shampoo

% Ugliness:
1. Ukyo 2. Ryoga 3. Happosai 4. Akane 5. Shampoo 6. Kodachi

Ave Ugliness:
1. Ukyo 2. Kodachi 3. Akane 4. Happosai 5. Ryoga 6. Shampoo

Ave Ugliness, not counting worst moment:
1. Ukyo 2. Kodachi 3. Akane 4. Happosai 5. Shampoo 6. Ryoga

Ave Net Good:
1. Ryoga 2. Akane 3. Ukyo 4. Shampoo 5. Happosai 6. Kodachi

Ave Net Good, not counting best moment:
1. Ryoga. 2. Akane 3. Ukyo 4. Shampoo 5. Happosai 6. Kodachi

In the anime:

% Good:
1. Ukyo 2. Shampoo 3. Akane 4. Kodachi

% Bad:
1. Ukyo 2. Akane 3. Shampoo 4. Kodachi

% Ugly:
1. Ukyo 2. Shampoo 3. Akane 4. Kodachi

Best moment:
1. Akane 2. Kodachi 3. Ukyo 4. Shampoo

Worst moment:
1. Ukyo 2. Kodachi and Shampoo (tie score) 4. Akane

% Ugliness:
1. Ukyo 2. Shampoo 3. Kodachi 4. Akane

Ave Ugliness:
1. Shampoo 2. Ukyo 3. Akane 4. Kodachi

Ave Ugliness, not counting worst moment:
1. Shampoo 2. Ukyo 3. Akane 4. Kodachi

Ave Net Good:
1. Akane 2. Ukyo 3. Shampoo 4. Kodachi

Ave Net Good, not counting best moment:
1. Akane 2. Ukyo 3. Shampoo 4. Kodachi


The Net Good of an episode is the number of Goods in an appearance, minus the number of Bads in the appearance. Appearances with Uglies are not counted. The 'Best Moment' score is the appearance with the highest Net Good.

I'd say the next thing on the list is the rivals, since FriendlyEl is already partway through the manga counterparts.