Josh has been reading ahead in the raw chapters and commenting privately, so as not to give away spoilers. I just asked him if we could post those here so that you all can see his impressions. They'll be posted as the chapters come out.
**********
Chapter 6:Josh: Well I just read ch6. Expected something like that with the time loop. Standard SM fair. Nothing new to say. Has the expected timing issues. The Spirit of Terra coming out was neat, but... Well the whole chapter was going to be contrived. Still painful.
Chapter 7:Josh: This has better pacing and the humor's crisper. Terra's introspection is better here. One cares about her more. You have that much at least.
Ben: Her personality does develop as the story goes on, yeah.
Josh: However the rest of the cast are still complete cutouts.
Ben: Yeah, one of the unfortunate side-effects of doing a story focusing on Terra in a compressed form has been that any other characters don't get the treatment they deserve. I can't do a Minako-only episode, for example. Or perhaps I can... Well, fleshing out takes time and size. I'd do that in NETTG Classic without hesitation; have a bunch of scenes describing characters' feelings and interaction. I simply didn't include it in this format.
Josh: You can try for a balance. To commit the horrible faux-pas of mentioning my own work, "The Return" has a second tier cast of probably 30 people, and balancing them in relation to the central tier of a dozen... not to mention keeping the main cast in perspective. It's hard, but I think it's worth it. The problem with concentrating on just Terra is that anyone else she repeatedly comes into contact with isn't fleshed out. An improvement, but still not much happens.
Ben: Took a couple years to finish the story, so I suppose I adapted to the format gradually. May need to do more heavy work on the first few chapters then.
Josh: You might want to invest in condensing this fic. Making it like 14 chapters or something.
Ben: Hmm... Could work. My guidelines for chapters were ~30k in size, and if I went above that I was probably doing something wrong, so went my internal suggestions. I planned for 25 chapters and still ended up with 27.
Josh: Well... look at what happens in each chapter. Is that the level of plot you feel comfortable with? I also hope you don't mind this digest form. Me sending a few paras for each chapter.
Ben: No, that's good. Very good, actually. When I finally emailed chapter 27 to Larry, Esa, Chesu, and Jason Hanks, the first email I got back was from Larry chewing me out about how much he didn't like the story. ^^
Larry:
Hey, I didn't chew you out. I said that there were things I absolutely hated, but I pointed them out and told you exactly why I didn't like them.Josh: As opposed to my chewing you out?
Ben: The first email I got from Esa about it was basically, ">_<;; Epilogue please," because the story's ending does leave a fair bit open. But Esa did comment about the story as a whole that, "It's good... very good." I do agree that the story isn't really what my style has been thus far, though.
Josh: Hrm. It glimmers through. It's just not as sharp as your style was before. You are finding your voice again. So far the chapters seem a bit better.
Chapter 8:Josh: Ah, here we go. Villians being right and proper. Brainwashing and killing. Hmm... I assume sailor V is different from Sailor Venus this time around. And Bruce. And Terra's using the "royal we" in her internal thoughts Stargate reference, heh. So far this is the best chapter yet. It doesn't have the odd pacing issues that the previous ones had. Of course there was no lagging introductions, no rushed introductions, no major battles that were IMO botched, just a simple "episode" that advanced the plot nicely.